Overpopulation of free-roaming cats drives hunt for better contraceptive
By ACES Research
July 20, 2018
  • /ACES
  • /Feature Areas
  • /A Healthy Planet
  • /ACES News
  • /Animal Sciences
  • /Office of Research

URBANA, Ill. – While the true number of free-roaming cats in the United States is unknown, experts believe the population may rival that of pet cats, with estimates ranging from 70 million to 90 million. This staggering number contributes substantially to cat overpopulation and the estimated 1.4 million cats euthanized each year in this country alone.

"Uncontrolled reproduction in free-roaming cats is a major problem in the United States and abroad," said Kelly Diehl, Senior Scientific and Communications Adviser at Morris Animal Foundation. "While there are excellent trap and neuter programs, many communities just don't have the intensive resources needed for this type of long-term surgical intervention. There needs to be a faster, easier, and less expensive method than surgery to address the health and welfare in free-roaming cats on a global scale."

Morris Animal Foundation-funded researchers at the Alliance for Contraception in Cats and Dogs embarked on a project to determine if GonaCon™, a nonsurgical contraceptive used in some wildlife species, might provide a solution. The results, unfortunately, were not as promising for fertility control of free-roaming cats as previously indicated.

Although vaccinated cats took longer to get pregnant and their litters were smaller than control cats in the study, the GonaCon vaccine only provided contraception for a minimum of one year in 30 percent of treated cats. Findings from the study recently were published in the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery.

"As expected, all 10 control cats became pregnant within a few months of the breeding trial," said Amy Fischer of the Department of Animal Sciences at the University of Illinois. "What was unexpected, based on the earlier study, was that 60 percent of the 20 GonaCon-treated cats were also pregnant within the same timeframe. By one year post-treatment, that number rose to 70 percent of GonaCon-treated cats. This tells us that the current EPA-approved formulation of GonaCon does not have sufficient real-world efficacy to pursue as a nonsurgical contraceptive for free-roaming cats."

An earlier study, also funded by Morris Animal Foundation, found cats vaccinated with GonaCon had a median duration of 39.7 months contraception. Based on these data, researchers were hopeful that a single injection of the GonaCon contraceptive would safely prevent pregnancy in female cats for about three years. Researchers note the differences in results between these two studies may be due to a slight change in the formulation of the vaccine or that the study was conducted in a very different and varied population of cats: cats living in colony conditions, as opposed to more tightly controlled laboratory conditions.

But that shift in study design does represent a win for the Alliance team – it's a big step forward in designing trials that will help researchers eventually come up with the right answer for surgical contraception. Their novel research model better represents the target population of free-roaming cats.

"We assembled a colony of socialized cats from high-risk circumstances and housed them in a behaviorally enriched, animal-centered facility that allowed for sufficient monitoring and containment for research, but also offered the cats exposure to a natural outdoor setting and colony hierarchy," Fischer said. "We will continue to use this model to inform future contraceptive studies in free-roaming cats in our efforts to find an effective and long-term solution to improve the health and welfare of cats everywhere."

The article, “Effectiveness of GonaCon as an immunocontraceptive in colony-housed cats,” is published in Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery [DOI: 10.1177/1098612X18758549]. Authors include Amy Fischer, Valerie Benka, Joyce Briggs, Marc-Antoine Driancourt, Joanne Maki, Darcy Mora, Kevin Morris, Kayla Myers, Linda Rhodes, Lindsey Vansandt, George Robert Weedon, Julie Wolf, and Julie Levy. Funding for the study came from the Morris Animal Foundation and the John T and Jane A Wiederhold Foundation.